Fitting Windscreen
Several things guys;
Glass with mouldings are rare now, so the average installer probably hasn't a clue. I know there are good ones, experienced with older cars..... far and few.
BMW had window tools to help remove and install. The purpose of the tool was to move the gasket around and hook the grooves so the lip would cover. The hook has to be curved so you don't catch the edge of the glass.
Glass then was originaly worked, ground to fit the opening with a clearance all around so it floats in the gasket. So placement is important; if it touches, you hit a bump.... well we all know the rest. So if you've done major work, place the glass in the opening and make sure you have clearance. Rope- the purpose of the rope is to also aid in keeping the clearance and keep the glass from shifting so gaps/ gaskets are in the proper orientation.
The gasket- as Chris points out, they're not all the same. Compounds, dimensions, age, etc. can cause the gasket to be less than optimum. OEM. Lay them out in the sun, hot water, etc. Always save the old ones for comparison.
The manual says to start inserting the trim in the gasket at the corner. What happens is that area needs the most slack in the gasket to cover the curve. If done otherwise, the gasket has to stretch in the corner and becomes narrow which is less optimum. The trim in this area can pinch inwards and compound the issue.(Easy as you remove it)
In place and ready to start.... the glass/ rubber/ lip has to be coaxed into position... soap, glass cleaner, etc.... rope... not the wire... pulled in small increments , side to side while applying pressure and slaps with the palm of your hand to seat the glass and rubber lip ( the hidden ones, one with sealer.) If the lip is having a hard time... use the tool.. the gasket is slightly twisted and rolled in.( More than just the outside lip)
If both top corners are out.... start over... beginning at the top. The glass has probably slid downward. One side out... shift the glass towards the opening.
Over time.. all rubber shrinks. But the picture below shows that there are probably multiple things adding up to a bad situation for a new install.
One other thing... storage of glass- on edge. Compound curved glass can warp otherwise. In that case, you have to push out on the glass from the inside while coaxing the gasket to hold.
Two good links for review:
http://www.bmw2002faq.com/component...page,viewtopic/t,278563/highlight,windshield/
http://www.bmw2002faq.com/component...iewtopic/t,342752/highlight,winshield+install
Hope this helps.