I have experience with BFG Comp Sport II on my Forester XT and Extreme Contact DW on my E46 wagon. Neither were nearly as good a tire as the Michelin Pilot Sport AS3 that replaced the BFG on the Subaru. My complaints with the Conti were diminished steering feel and response on the E46 (These replaced excellent Michelin PS2 tires) The BFG quickly became very, very loud on the Subaru and lacked on centre precision. The ride was harsh too. the Michelin AS3's are a delight. Huge grip for an all season, excellent steering response, ride and rain performance. I'll probably be buying these for my Coupe, especially since Summer tires are pretty dicey in Canada early Spring and Fall. Each car is different I suppose, so no idea how they work on a Coupe.