3D printed ignition switch repair option

davekillen

Member
Messages
41
Reaction score
43
Location
Portland, OR
I've been experimenting with a couple of e3 ignition switches that I've ended up with. Both had the same problem, which I understand is common, of not being able to turn the electronic portion of the switch far enough to engage the "start" position.

I took apart the steering lock assemblies and determined that the problem with both was wear on the ends of the intermediate shaft that connects the ignition barrel to the electronic switch. I also noticed similar wear in the end of the ignition barrels. Altogether, this created enough slop that the electronic switch wouldn't move completely through its range to "start" when the key was turned all the way.

I know new steering lock assemblies are available, but I also know there are a few different types and I wasn't confident that I'd end up with the correct one. So, I decided to try to copy the intermediate shaft in Fusion 360.

After a few iterations, I have a design that works! It's a pretty faithful copy of the original metal piece with the exception of extending the ignition barrel end by 1mm to help it reach past any wear on the end of the tumbler socket.

It needs to be printed out of a stiff material... even once I had the design down, the test prints I made with PLA would twist too much axially and not engage the start position on the electronic switch. When printed in carbon-fiber reinforced nylon, though, it works great.

The only issue with that is that with the nozzle I have the carbon fiber filament is kind of a low-resolution version of the part, and needed some cleanup with a file. But, maybe another stiff filament would work, or a print using a finer nozzle (I'm pretty limited in the nozzles and filament I have on hand right now).

Anyway, I thought maybe this could help someone else. I don't know durable this will be in the long run, but I'm going to try using it for now and see how it goes (this photo is of one of the PLA test prints). If anyone wants the file just let me know, I don't think I can post it here.

IMG_7025.JPG
Screenshot 2026-03-24 144907.png
 
Last edited:
Expertly done part, especially considering how much overhang there is!

My favorite 3D printing trick is to design a hole through the middle of the part and then drive a screw in as a final step. Voila, a perfect plastic part with a steel spine that won't bend or twist. In this case I can't tell if the shaft would be too narrow make hollow. It would require a pretty particular screw, like M2 x 100mm or something.

Great reverse engineering!
 
Great work.
I'd like a copy of the model , can work with Fusion (beginner level though).
Having the model also will allow to get a qoute for a metal 3d print.
If it works in a plastic 3d print, but the torsion is critical, then we have little other options than moving to metal.

I'll pm you
 
@davekillen - would e9 ignition barrels have the same design? Thus same problem, thus same solution with your part?
Yup, it's the same part I believe, though there are a few different steering lock barrels apparently, depending on year, per this very helpful thread: https://e9coupe.com/forum/threads/how-to-deal-with-the-clausor-and-ignition-switch.23593/

This part I've re-created is present what the author of that thread identifies as the type B steering locks.

I'll send you the printer file now via email!
 
Expertly done part, especially considering how much overhang there is!

My favorite 3D printing trick is to design a hole through the middle of the part and then drive a screw in as a final step. Voila, a perfect plastic part with a steel spine that won't bend or twist. In this case I can't tell if the shaft would be too narrow make hollow. It would require a pretty particular screw, like M2 x 100mm or something.

Great reverse engineering!
I think it'd be tough to run a screw through the center because much of the shaft is a half-moon shape. But that's a great idea for other applications, thanks! I'm relatively new to 3D printing so any tips like that are helpful
 
Back
Top