PPG vs. Glasurit

bavbob

Well-Known Member
Site Donor
Messages
3,827
Reaction score
1,931
Location
Boston, Ma
So my e21 is off to get painted. When I had the E9 painted there was a clear difference between PPG and Glasurit Taiga, the Glasurit was a tad lighter and just popped compared to the PPG. The e21 is anthracite grey metallic. Is my observation based on the e9 an N=1 or have others found Glasurit to be superior in appearance? Painter said he would do either, my choice. Thanks
 
you should put up pics of the 2 paint samples (with no names) and see the unbiased reaction. my thought is the tad lighter would be a better choice. i think that is true with taiga and turkis ... maybe with ceylon
 
Rob & Scott-- No photo posted on any monitor or phone will give you the true colors. I found that out when the shop that painted my Turkis compared the PPG sample with the metal sample Jon Iverson sent me painted with Turkis Glasurit. The PPG painted on a sample had at least 5 coats and still didn't have the rich color they got with just 2 coats of Glasurit. You have to see a metal sample painted with both paints in the outdoor light to make a decision. The metal "specs" in Glasurit are unique to their paint. I have seen Mercedes and Porsches with showcar finishes and found out they were Glasurit. The clear coat needs to be at least 5-7 coats where 2-3 coats are wet sanded off to have a pro-finish. But you already know that...
 
while i agree with you Drew ... my point was to see a pic of two actual paintout samples on metal. if the color is generally correct shade, you can get a good sense of value of the painted sample because the question was that the glasurit was a tad lighter and more 'pop' ... which is what your comment on turkis was.

now in relation to turkis, was your ppg sample a solvent based or a water based? did it have a clear coat on the samples? for instance, with ceylon, glasurit said their new ceylon formula was not a perfect match to the original and had to be altered for touch up on original paint. if you were painting the entire car, it would be quite similar but not a perfect match ... their words, not mine. new glasurit is not the same as old glasurit formulas ... in california, the vast majority of paint is water based. my ppg ceylon is water based but the clear is solvent.
 
Weighing in on this the size of the metallic flakes is also important. I found Glaserit had smaller particles of metallic and was more subtle than other paints. Glaserit is the OEM paint BMW uses and when you're going to the trouble and expense to paint your Coupe, I think, going with Glaserit/OEM is the best solution.
Regards, Jon
 
I had my car painted in PPG. Initially my painter told me he could shoot Glasurit but then changed his mind. I would have preferred Glasurit, the jobs I have seen in Glaurit and much richer. Keep in mind Glasurit will be 25% -40% more expensive. Also in many states ban Glasurit. I thought Massachusetts banned
 
the question is solvent based or water based. the most accurate ppg are water based. IMHO, solvent based are the best paints. glasurit solvent and ppg water are not much different in price. i looked at the glasurit ceylon and i didn't like it, it was too brown. keep in mind, what i love is the original glasurit ceylon. my 2nd + 3rd favorite are granatrot and baikal, closely followed by turkis and taiga. i haven't looked at the glasurit / ppg versions of each of those colors ... but my favorites are based on the original glasurit formulas (which no longer exist). with ppg, only the water based paints have a chance at being excellent ... but IMHO they won't be as rich as the original solvent based Glasurit formulas.

if the metallic isn't the very small flake of the original, it isn't worth talking about. the metallic ceylon from ppg was correct flake.
 
Ives is correct. One of the major considerations is the size of metallic flake. PPG is good but cannot compare to the OEM look of Glasurit. I find that Glasurit is more forgiving in the critical base coat application stage as it provides a more consistent application (no shadows or zebra striping) than other paints. More expensive yes, totally worth it.
 
Do you feel that those differences hold true throughout the paint color line, i.e. my car is Polaris Silver, which doesn't necessarily seem to have the "depth" that some of the other colors such as Ceylon or Turkis have, where I can see that the differences in one paint vs another reveal themselves not only in the flake but also the vibrancy of the color. Since I'm considering repaint in the Polaris, am I also going to be trying to assess these issues?
 
We painted my Polaris 2800 with ProSpray and I think PPG Clear, it looks great as Paul will attest. The e9 was ProSpray single stage Chamonix, also looks good.
 
When I had Sixto painted in 2013 the paint shop artist shot 2 samples of Glaserit Turkis. I loaned these sample to Drew to help him decide on color/ brand. One was base coat and the other was with clear. They used it to get my approval and I thought "what do I know?". I'm glad I was in good hands at the time as someone said later "I was the only one that got out alive" from that shop. The artist/paint booth person is very important in the formula and maybe when you're having your Coupe painted get a look at that specific person's work. My artist on Sixto Turkis left shortly after doing my Coupe and I think the shop saw a significant drop in quality for later Coupes.
Regards, Jon
 
i think that is true ... luckily the owner of the shop was the artist that painted my coupe. there are a few errors, but only in places that won't show unless you are really looking. with metallics it matters a lot on the settings, the uniformity of spraying, etc.
 
Do you feel that those differences hold true throughout the paint color line, i.e. my car is Polaris Silver, which doesn't necessarily seem to have the "depth" that some of the other colors such as Ceylon or Turkis have, where I can see that the differences in one paint vs another reveal themselves not only in the flake but also the vibrancy of the color. Since I'm considering repaint in the Polaris, am I also going to be trying to assess these issues?
I saw an award winning silver Mercedes 190 SL that was a complete nut and bolt restoration at a local show. The owner just got the car back from Germany. I asked if it was Glasurit and he called the shop in Germany since it was a friend who did the work. He confirmed it was Glasurit.
I also just saw a 1959 356 Porsche that was an amazing restoration. It was silver Glasurit. You can tell the difference once you have seen the Glasurit in person.
 
since most glasurit paints have been solvent based, it depends on state laws on using that type of product ... getting harder every year.
 
Back
Top