And they will do it from a pic but use generic brand keys.I had duplicate keys made by keys4classics.com in Australia.
To close this thread again... BMD dealer had the wrong key. I'm going to get generic metal keys from Santa Monica lock and key.Just to close this thread, I was able to buy blanks from my BMW dealer in Dallas. I wanted the original OEM key with the black plastic that says BMW vs an all metal key. Santa Monica Lock and Key will make duplicates with a picture of the one good key I have. Not cheap, but100% OEM.