Okay, to my surprise it just arrived this afternoon. Here's some photos. Its definitely a Hartge valuve cover, it has headers that similar to Hartge but I didn't look for a tag. I took a photo of the oil pan but I don't know if its anything special. Number on the head seems stock. The steering wheel is a MOMO and the transmission shifts like a standard 5-spd. I'll get it up on a lift at some point and see if there's anything underneath. I had slated this car for parts but its actually in really good shape so I have them mark it as a "Builder" for now until I find out more. Its also a clear title car.
My gut feel with this car is that its a stock 533i/is with a valve cover and some bolt-on cosmetics.